Of the approximately 4,000 known burials in the Old Burying Ground, three per cent of the burials are of persons described as Colored. The following names are a few of those who have been identified. Research is continuing on identifying those who are buried in this cemetery
| Name | Date of Death | Age | Remarks |
| Antony, Heneritta V. | 13 May 1846 | 1yl0m | |
| Atkinson, Elsey | 26 Jul 1843 | 84 | |
| Atkinson, Francis | 13 Sep 1841 | 25 | Parish |
| Atkinson, Rien | 14 Dec 1839 | 19 | |
| Barrett, Cyrus | 27 Sep 1840 | 39 | Seaman, native of Boston |
| Baxter, Charlet A. | 19 Apr 1841 | 1y7m14d | |
| Benton, Almer C. | 09 Aug 1845 | 28 | |
| Blister, Charles E. | 06 Jun 1841 | 1y2m | |
| Bowen, Heneritta | 22 Apr 1842 | 42 | |
| Brister, Ann V. | 26 Jun 1840 | 1y7m | Parish |
| Brister, Elizabeth | 21 Jul 1845 | 63 | Widow |
| Brister, John E. | 01 Jun 1842 | 1y5m | |
| Brister, Lunen | 07 May 1844 | 23 | |
| Brister, William H. | 02 Feb 1841 | 8y9m | |
| Brooks, Lucinda | 03 Aug 1839 | 2 | |
| Brown, John M. | 21 Oct 1841 | 1y4m | |
| Burns, Mary Jane | 17 Mar 1842 | 2d | |
| Burr, Emma | 10 Nov 1847 | 62 | |
| Burr, Nancy | 05 Oct 1844 | 11m | |
| Burr, Nancy | 27 Jan 1845 | 43 | |
| Burr, Sarah A. | 17 Mar 1840 | 18 | Parish |
| Campbell, Arene | 05 Jan 1845 | 54 | |
| Clements, Charlot | 05 Jul 1846 | 37 | |
| Collins, Augusta | 08 Oct 1842 | 9m | Parish |
| Collins, Nary A. | 16 May 1845 | 20 | |
| Cooper, Wellington | 10 Feb 1841 | 4y11m | Parish |